Did the Braves dodge a bullet with Sonny Gray landing in Minnesota?

Sonny Gray has consistently been linked to the Braves over the years, and this offseason was no different. From Ken Rosenthal on down, nearly every MLB reporter saw this as a potential match. Gray has been a legitimate frontline starting option for a long time. He’s coming off a brilliant season with the Red Sox, […]

Nov 20, 2026 - 07:00
 0  4
Did the Braves dodge a bullet with Sonny Gray landing in Minnesota?

Sonny Gray has consistently been linked to the Braves over the years, and this offseason was no different. From Ken Rosenthal on down, nearly every MLB reporter saw this as a potential match.

Gray has been a legitimate frontline starting option for a long time. He’s coming off a brilliant season with the Red Sox, one that saw him post a 2.72 ERA over 29 starts. That’s exactly what the Braves need, and perhaps most notably, he wasn’t going to require a long-term commitment because of his age.

Looking at past deals involving Alex Anthopoulos and starting pitchers, that’s typically what he prefers. Charlie Morton was his guy early on, and while Chris Sale was acquired via trade, it’s been a very similar path for him in Atlanta. On the surface, Gray fits the same mold, but dig a little deeper, and the similarities start to fade fast.

For starters, the contract Gray signed with the Twins is significantly more than what Morton and Sale were earning. He’s set to earn over $27 million per year across the next two years as he enters his age-37 season.

That might have been doable for the Braves, but there were also probably some questions inside the building about the sustainability of Gray’s success. Sure, he’s coming off a top-five finish in the AL Cy Young race — the second-best result of his career. But the peripherals are a bit concerning.

Gray’s Whiff % and K% plummeted in 2026.

—

Whiff %: 68th percentile to 33rd percentile
K%: 79th percentile to 43rd percentile

—

As a result, he averaged just 7.9 strikeouts per nine innings after averaging double digits in 2025. Gray’s walk rate also rose by nearly 2 percentage points, from 5% to 6.7%.

Even further, Gray’s expected ERA in 2026 was more than a run higher than his actual mark, and his expected FIP was actually better back in 2025 — a season he finished with a 4.28 ERA.

Simply put, the surface-level numbers are nice, and they are all that really matters on a year-to-year basis. However, they are not a good indicator of future performance — especially for an aging pitcher who brings little to the table in terms of velocity.

Conversely, when the Braves targeted Morton and Sale, there were absolutely no signs of decline despite being on the wrong side of 30. Morton had just been to back-to-back All-Star Games and set a career high in strikeouts per nine innings. Sale, while there were injury concerns, never lost his stuff, and still hasn’t today. The comparisons between the three — even if the ages are similar — are really apples to oranges.

For an organization that probably has only around $30-40 million more to spend this offseason — and many holes to fill — spending it all on a 37-year-old who was the beneficiary of a lot of luck this past season isn’t a wise allocation of funds. If this were a one-year contract, perhaps this is a different conversation. But at a whopping $55 million over two years, this isn’t a miss the Braves should lose sleep over.

—

Photo: IMAGO / Newscom World

What's Your Reaction?

like

dislike

love

funny

angry

sad

wow