Did the Falcons end up with the worst QB from the 2024 NFL Draft?
Folks can keep arguing back and forth about Michael Penix Jr., but most level-headed analysts seem to agree: there are too many red flags to continue hoping he can be an NFL franchise quarterback. Penix is the worst quarterback in football under pressure. Not a good sign, and even worse when you consider he’s also […]
Folks can keep arguing back and forth about Michael Penix Jr., but most level-headed analysts seem to agree: there are too many red flags to continue hoping he can be an NFL franchise quarterback.
Penix is the worst quarterback in football under pressure. Not a good sign, and even worse when you consider he’s also terribly inaccurate in the quick passing game. He also can’t throw to his right. Add it all up, and the Falcons basically have a quarterback who needs perfect protection on long-developing deep routes to one side of the field.
That’s before we even get into the injury concerns, which could be the most damning aspect of it all. Penix has had a slew of injuries dating back to his college days, including three different ACL surgeries. Atlanta will be back in the quarterback market this offseason, whether they continue to roster Penix or not.
It’s even more frustrating when you take a look at the 2024 quarterback class. Six quarterbacks were taken in the top 12 picks, and a case could be made that Penix is the worst of the bunch.
Caleb Williams might be the best quarterback in the entire league. Jayden Daniels hasn’t been able to stay healthy consistently, but when he’s on the field, he’s a star, and Drake Maye has already been to the Super Bowl.
All of those options were taken in the top three picks, so the Falcons can’t really lose sleep over what could have been. However, I would argue both Bo Nix and even J.J. McCarthy have a better chance of sticking around as a starter longer than Michael Penix.
The case for Nix is obvious. He has his warts, but he led the Broncos to the AFC Championship in his second season and accounted for 30 total touchdowns. The upside might be lacking, but he’s at least a steady presence under center who has proven he can perform well under pressure.
McCarthy is a bit of a hot take. He was horrendous for the Vikings last season, and Minnesota wasted no time giving up on him, shipping him to New York for a fraction of their initial investment. But it’s starting to look like that move might have been premature.
McCarthy has been a respectable option for the Giants since they named him the starting quarterback, and there were a number of throws he made under pressure last Thursday night against the Commanders that Penix simply cannot make. Would it really be that surprising if McCarthy went on to have a better NFL career than Penix? I would say it’s a toss-up right now at best.
The previous regime completely screwed the organization. Three years ago, they had gobs of cap space, a decent roster, and a top 10 pick in the draft. They wasted that cap space on Kirk Cousins and the draft pick on Michael Penix Jr. in one of the most dumbfounding sequences of events in NFL history. Unsurprisingly, it’s cost Falcons fans three years they’ll never get back. Hopefully, they don’t make it a fourth by relying on Penix to start again next season.
—
Photo: IMAGO / Icon Sportswire
What's Your Reaction?

